· ·

Cashmere Vs. Cotton: Which Makes the Best Sweaters

Cashmere and cotton sweaters, both by J. Crew

When shopping for winter sweaters, you’ve probably noticed that cotton and cashmere are two of the most common choices. While there’s room for both in any wardrobe, the reasons for buying cashmere vs. cotton are pretty different. Each brings its unique vibe to the fashion table, from the luxurious touch of cashmere to the everyday versatility of cotton.

Let’s unravel the mysteries of cashmere and cotton, guiding you through your next plush or practical purchase. We’ll touch on the origin of each fiber, cost comparison, sustainability, durability, care instructions, and more.

Understanding Cashmere and Cotton

What is Cashmere?

Image via Shutterstock

Cashmere, the epitome of luxury, is not just any wool but is sourced from the soft undercoat of cashmere goats found in the harsh climates of Mongolia, China, and Iran. This rare fiber is renowned for its incredible softness, warmth, and lightweight properties, making it a coveted material for high-end sweaters, scarves, and even suits. Cashmere’s appeal lies in its delicate texture and cozy warmth, making it a winter wardrobe staple for those looking for the perfect marriage of comfort and style.

What is Cotton?

On the other end of the fabric spectrum lies cotton, the workhorse of the textile world. Derived from the cotton plant, this natural fiber is beloved for its breathability, durability, and easy maintenance. The versatility of cotton is unmatched, making its way into everything from basic tees and denim to bedding and towels. Cotton’s widespread use across various fashion segments speaks to its universal appeal, offering a comfortable and hypoallergenic option for daily wear.

Cost Comparison

A cashmere sweater by The Row, costing more than $3,000.

One of the biggest differences between cotton and cashmere is the cost, with cashmere generally coming in at double or triple the price of cotton. However, if you look at the price per wear, the costs being to even out…

Initial Cost

When it comes to upfront costs, cotton generally takes the lead as the more wallet-friendly option. Cotton sweaters average anywhere from $40-$150, though luxury options can cost upwards of $400. The accessibility and abundant supply of cotton keep prices relatively low, making it a go-to for everyday clothing needs. Cashmere, however, commands a higher price tag, generally costing anywhere from $80-$400 per garment, with luxury brands charging close to $1,000 or more. This reflects not just its status as a luxury item, but the time-consuming process of collecting and refining the fibers. Investing in cashmere is often seen as a splurge, reserved for special occasions or high-quality, timeless pieces.

Long-Term Value

The initial sticker shock of cashmere can be justified by its longevity and timeless appeal. With proper care, a cashmere garment can be a lifelong wardrobe staple, often becoming softer with age. Cotton, while durable, tends to have a shorter lifespan, especially in frequently worn and washed items. However, its lower cost means replacing cotton items doesn’t hit the wallet as hard, offering a budget-friendly cycle of wardrobe refreshment.

Cashmere vs. Cotton: Care Instructions

A cashmere sweater from Jenni Kayne, coming in at $185.

Cashmere Care

Caring for cashmere requires a bit more attention than your average fabric. To maintain its softness and prevent damage, hand washing or dry cleaning is recommended, along with flat drying to preserve shape. Pilling can occur with friction but can be gently removed with a cashmere comb, extending the garment’s pristine condition.

Cotton Care

Cotton’s care regimen is decidedly less fussy. Machine washable and durable, cotton items can withstand high temperatures and repeated washings. Ironing can vary from unnecessary for casual tees to essential for crisp cotton shirts, making it a versatile fabric that fits into the hustle and bustle of daily life.

As we’ve peeled back the layers of cashmere and cotton, it’s clear that each fabric holds its own in the fashion arena, catering to different needs, preferences, and lifestyles. Stay tuned as we delve deeper into the sustainability, environmental impact, and how to make the choice that best suits your wardrobe and values.

Cashmere vs. Cotton: Sustainability

Environmental Impact of Cashmere Production

The allure of cashmere’s softness comes with its own set of sustainability challenges. The increasing demand for this luxurious fabric has led to an expansion in goat herds, which, in turn, strains the delicate ecosystems where these animals graze. Overgrazing can lead to severe land degradation, transforming once fertile lands into deserts, a phenomenon that not only disrupts local biodiversity but also the traditional nomadic lifestyles reliant on these landscapes. The sustainability of cashmere production is a complex issue, urging both producers and consumers to consider the environmental cost behind the luxury.

Environmental Impact of Cotton Production

Cotton, while seemingly innocuous as a plant-based fiber, carries its own environmental baggage. It’s a thirsty crop, requiring significant amounts of water to grow—contributing to water scarcity in arid regions. Additionally, conventional cotton farming heavily relies on pesticides and fertilizers, which can leach into ecosystems, harming wildlife and affecting human health. However, the rise of organic cotton offers a beacon of hope, promoting methods that reduce water usage and eliminate harmful chemicals, albeit at a higher cost.

Durability and Performance

Lifespan of Cashmere

Despite its delicate reputation, cashmere, when cared for properly, boasts remarkable durability. Its fibers are naturally more resilient than wool, capable of stretching and returning to shape without damage. Pilling, a common grievance among cashmere owners, is a manageable issue; regular de-pilling can keep garments looking new. Investing time in cashmere care—washing gently, storing correctly—can significantly extend its lifespan, making it a worthy heirloom piece in your wardrobe.

Lifespan of Cotton

Cotton’s durability is one of its standout features, enduring countless washes and wears with grace. While not immune to wear and tear, cotton garments can last years, if not decades, with minimal care. Its performance under various conditions—from hot summer days to layered winter outfits—makes cotton a reliable fabric choice for a broad range of apparel. However, its susceptibility to shrinking and fading means a little extra care is necessary to maintain the garment’s original appeal.

The cashmere vs. cotton debate underscores a broader conversation about personal values, lifestyle, and environmental responsibility in fashion choices. Cashmere, with its luxurious feel and higher price point, appeals to those seeking indulgence and longevity in their garments, provided they’re ready to commit to its care and consider its environmental implications. On the other hand, cotton offers versatility, comfort, and a more straightforward care routine, appealing to eco-conscious consumers, especially when opting for organic varieties.

Your choice between cashmere and cotton ultimately hinges on what you value most: the luxury and warmth of cashmere or the everyday practicality and sustainability of cotton. Both fabrics have their place in a thoughtful wardrobe, each offering unique benefits and challenges.